Thomas Lynch Oral History Transcript
Media
Part of Tom Lynch Oral History
content
Thomas Lynch
Marist College
Poughkeepsie, NY
Transcribed by Kyra Walker
For the Marist College Archives and Special Collections
Thomas Lynch
Transcript – Thomas Lynch
Interviewee:
Thomas Lynch
Interviewer:
Gus Nolan
Interview Date:
26 March 2019
Location:
Marist Archives and Special Collections
Topic:
Marist College History
Subject Headings:
Lynch, Thomas
Marist Brothers—United States—History
Marist College—History
Marist College (Poughkeepsie, N.Y.)
Marist College—Environmental Science
Summary:
Tom Lynch provides insight to his background as a professor in environmental science. He
reflects on the growth of the environmental science department at Marist, and the changes that
that college and its students has undergone throughout the years.
Gus Nolan (00:02):
Today is Tuesday, the 26th of March. Now we have the opportunity to interview a retired professor,
Tom Lynch from the environmental sciences. Good Afternoon Tom.
Tom Lynch (01:06):
Good Afternoon Gus, glad to be here.
GN (01:08):
Thank you. I wonder, we're going to start by kind of a general overview. Kind of a thumbnail overview of
your life, your early years, where you grew up and kind of give us an idea of where you're coming from.
TL (01:25):
Okay.
GN (01:26):
So where would you say, born in the eastern United States? You can give me more detail.
TL (01:31):
I was born in Bridgeport, Connecticut--lived there, went to Catholic elementary school, Catholic high
school. I went to the University of Bridgeport where I got bachelors and master's degrees in biology. I
taught high school science in Monroe, Connecticut for two years. And then I decided to go back for my
PhD degree in aquatic ecology with the fisheries and wildlife department at Michigan State University.
So I spent five years living in Michigan getting my...working on my PhD. And then my first job was with a
biology department out in the Southwest in a little town called Socorro, New Mexico.
GN (02:17):
Okay. Before we get into the professional, more things about the growing up. Special interests...you
seem to ban outdoorsman, so were you involved in sports as well?
TL (02:29):
I didn't get involved in the organized sports growing up. At that time, every kid...every house on the
block had three, four, or five kids. And so we played a lot of sandlot kind of stuff--baseball, football,
basketball, et cetera. It was very easy to put together two teams because like I say, everybody
had...every house had multiple kids, back in the middle of the baby boom there. And we used to spend a
lot of time outdoors. I mean where I grew up, it was a suburban area of Bridgeport and at the time it
was hundreds of acres of open space just down the street from us. And so we used to play Cowboys and
Indians and soldiers and we used to hunt and we used to sneak over to a private lake, which was maybe
300.
GN (03:29):
Alright, I didn't want to go there [laughter].
TL (03:31):
Well, one side was developed, the other side was not developed. So we used to sneak around to the
undeveloped side and fish and camp and stuff like that.
GN (03:41):
How about particular interests in your personal life. Talents...music or reading or a hobby and stamps
collection or anything like that?
TL (03:54):
Yeah, I did stamp collecting for a while when I was, I don't know, probably middle school age because
my grandfather had done it, so my father gave me some of my grandfather's stamp books. But I kind of
lost interest in that. And so I spent a lot of time reading. Like I say, a lot of times outdoors we would
come home from school and of course we always wore uniforms. So we very quickly change and you're
out the door until dinner time. And same thing on weekends, eight or nine o'clock in the morning, we
were gone, we'd show up for supper.
GN (04:33):
How big is the family of which you speak now?
TL (04:35):
I had three brothers and one sister. One brother is now deceased, the others are...the other siblings are
still alive. Two of them live over in the Bridgeport, Connecticut area. One lives in North Carolina. So-
GN (04:55):
Okay. Changing pace a little bit, what's the genesis of your coming to Marist? How did that happen?
TL (05:00):
Well, when I was working out in...well, I went to a Marist Brothers high school.
GN (05:05):
Where?
TL (05:05):
In Trumbull, Connecticut. So St. Joseph's High School. And so I was familiar with the Marist Brothers. My
older brother who's now deceased, he actually went into the Marist Brothers and spent one year in tins
Bureau. So he spent one year there and then left. And so I was familiar with the Marist Brothers and I
had heard of Marist College because of all the brothers. We had us as high school faculty. So then
I...after I finished my PhD degree, I...my first teaching job was at a school of science and engineering in
New Mexico, in the biology department. So I spent 12 years out there, eventually becoming department
chair. And then I saw an ad in the...this weekly journal called Science. You're looking for somebody to
teach environmental science at Marist College. And so I said my wife--who's from Yonkers--I said, should
I apply for it? Because when we initially moved out to this town, it was only town of 6,500. She said, I'll
give you two years and we're out of here. Because we were...being, she's from Yonkers, I'm from-
GN (06:23):
Your family is up here anyway.
TL (06:24):
Yeah, family was all here and just the whole...the greenery and stuff like that...the Southwest is just
brown and very different and a little wine vegetation. And the town was really small, 6,500. So, when
she took his first look at it, she saw I'd give you two years and we're out of here. Well, two years turned
into 12. And then...and so we have a lot of really good friends and stuff there. And so when I saw this ad
for Marist, and I had been developing an environmental science program at the Mexico Institute of
Mining and Technology. And so I said, well, should I apply for it? She said yeah, what have you got to
lose? So I applied for it. I came, I interviewed.
GN (07:09):
About what year was this?
TL (07:09):
This was in '91.
GN (07:12):
'91. So Dennis has in place as well?
TL (07:16):
Yeah, Dennis was already here. Andy Malloy was a chair of the department, or chair--I guess it wasn't
even a department yet--chair of the school of sciences, is what it was called. And so I interviewed, and
then Andy offered me the position. And so then-
GN (07:38):
Did you come as a biologist?
TL (07:39):
I came as an...they were recruiting for a director of the environmental science program. So I came in as
an associate professor because I was already tenured out at this other school and actually had just
gotten promoted to full professor. And so I came in with all my degrees are in basically biology. But they
hired me as the director of the environmental science program. And so-
GN (08:16):
Well let's just talk about Marist for a minute. In '91, certainly we've changed considerably since that day.
What would you say about that? What will you attribute or where do you see the biggest change in
Marist from '91 to-
TL (08:33):
Obviously just in size and the physical plant and stuff like that. I mean, I was reflecting on...anticipating
you probably asking that type of question. And so I think, I can't remember how many faculty there
were when I came. I know we all fit during plenaries into Donnelley 225 and within a couple of years I
think I probably pretty much knew everybody in the room.
GN (09:00):
Not for lunch where they had biology labs. Bill Pear was in there.
TL (09:06):
So we used to do, yeah. So Bill Pear died several weeks after I got here, so I only knew him for a couple
of weeks. Because we were in the same office suite together. So it was Bill and Andy and myself and
Vicky Ingalls. And Betty Jaycox was our secretary at the time.
GN (09:26):
Was LaPietra on the scene yet?
TL (09:28):
Richard LaPietra was here. Matt Polusny was here. Larry Menapace was here.
GN (09:35):
Was Richard in chemistry?
TL (09:37):
Richard was in chemistry. Richard, Andy Matt Polusny, and Larry Menapace were all in the chemistry
department.
GN (09:44):
Okay, and Bettencourt was in biology?
TL (09:46):
Bettencourt was in biology. Vicky Ingalls was in biology.
GN (09:54):
All right. I just...I'm trying to get historical things. Just comment this now in terms of Marist and its
growth and development. What was you think the greatest input for that? Was it Dennis or was it the
tradition or was it the student body or is the potential, where was going? How do you explain?
TL (10:15):
Oh, it's probably a combination of all of those things. I mean, Dennis certainly had his vision, although I
often didn't agree with the direction that he was taking the college fashionably in terms of the changes
that he was requiring of the faculty and stuff like that. And our priorities and those kinds of things. But I
think the reputation of the college kind of gradually grew and then certainly as we became larger, we've
got number of different programs. So even environmental science, I mean when I initially came, I was
the only person in environmental science and within three or four years we had hired Rich Feldman.
GN (11:07):
Okay, I want to get into that. But before that I want you to talk about...has there been a drastic change
in the student body in terms of anything? Is their spirit the same, their capabilities the same, their
backgrounds the same?
TL (11:24):
I mean I've taught...obviously I've taught a lot of the majors. I don't think the majors have changed all
that. The environmental science and policy majors, I don't think they've changed all that much. I think
they're probably comparable, maybe slightly better quality. But in terms of the of the non-majors,
because I taught a lot of those, because I used to teach introduction to environmental issues, probably
taught that course 60 plus times over the 27 years I was here. But I think there are a lot of those...or a
lot of the attitude of those...I mean, I think that writing has deteriorated. The ability to write as
deteriorated. The ability to do work outside of class I think has degenerated.
GN (12:17):
Really?
TL (12:18):
That was just my impression, particularly among the non-majors. There was a lot more, again from
my...we've had discussions about this with Vicky and Joe and whatever that the students now require a
lot more spoon-feeding. They want extra help sessions, they want review sheets.
GN (12:41):
Well, part of that I guess is also what you talked about you when you grew up, the families were five and
six, and now they're two and three, so parents are helicopting over-
TL (12:52):
They can get much more helicoptering parents. Certainly, whatever that education--I forget what the
name of it, where you can't talk to the parents without permission from the school. The Educational
Rights and Privacy Act, I guess.
GN (13:11):
Well, you can't send the grades to them.
TL (13:12):
You can't send the grades to me. You can't post grades anymore. So we used to just post grades by
social security number or student number, that kind of thing. You can't do that anymore. So a lot of that
has changed. And I think the students have just gotten more of an attitude of...I'm not sure what the
word I'm looking for. I used to lay it out with my students--particularly the non-majors--I said that the
average grade in this class, at the end of the course, it's going to be probably a C or C plus. And I--vividly-
-I remember one young lady sitting right in front of me and she's like, what do you mean the average is
going to be C plus. And I said, well we can't all be above average. A is above average, it's exceptional.
This is a link we'll be going where everybody's above average.
GN (14:12):
They call me C ++.
TL (14:12):
So I said, there's going to be A's, there's going to be F's. And I said, I've got no high expectations. I've
got...I'm pretty well calibrated. I'm happy to give you an A if you earn it, but I'm not going to...so there
was just more of a... I think in particular more in the last probably 10 or 15 years more of an attitude
that we're paying a lot of money for this education. You need to-
GN (14:40):
We deserve something from it.
TL (14:40):
You need to give us a good grade for the money that we're paying here.
GN (14:44):
Moreover, we write reports on you.
TL (14:48):
Yeah.
GN (14:50):
Changing the page to another issue, about environmental science--this was not a subject that I knew
about in college. We never talked about this.
TL (15:00):
Well, and when I was an undergraduate, it was never offered either. So Marist...so one of the first things
I had to do when I came, was Andy said, you need to do a program review. And so I had to delve into all
the records, enrollments and all this kind of stuff. So I was able to trace the environmental science
program back here to about 1974.
GN (15:27):
Really?
TL (15:28):
And then...so that would make it probably one of the oldest environmental science programs in four
year colleges because I mean, I graduated as an undergraduate in '71 and there were no colleges
offering environmental science programs at that point. And they really...the environmental science as a
separate discipline, or really as an interdisciplinary approach really didn't...I would say start to pick up
until the mid-1980s/late 1980s. And that's when I started putting this program together out in New
Mexico. And so I had some familiarity with it. I had built or designed the curriculum and stuff, but it was
undergoing review, et cetera. So when I came here in '91, they had just...Brian Hill was my predecessor
and he had just revised the whole program into a three-track program. I actually was into a two-track
program, science and policy. And prior to that timing, enrollments have been really, really low. And so
when I started here, 45 freshmen came in with me, which is the highest I think we've ever hit. So the
word had gotten out, Harry Woods was spending a lot of time promoting it. He would take me out on
some of his tours on college nights and stuff like that. So from like '91 to about '95, we had some really,
really strong freshmen classes in terms of numbers. But about same time lots of other schools were
developing environmental science program. So when I did review in '91 there were about 400 colleges
that offered environmental science programs. By about 1996 when we had to do another review, that
number jumped up to over 800 and now it's probably closer to a thousand, so with the expansion of the
number of schools offering the programs now the students were interested had double the number of
colleges to pick from. So our enrollment started a long slide starting. So we were...at one point, we were
at like 105 or 110 majors over the last probably 18 years. We probably in the neighborhood of 50 or 60
and we've never been able to push it up. We've never gotten below that. But you know, so over the last
15-18 years, we've been at a steady mid-fifties in terms of enrollment, never the kind of enrollment we
have from like '91 to '95.
GN (18:29):
But we've achieved that there's more opportunities now. I mean I always want to be interested. We had
one of the college magazines had you on the cover to vote the lab-
TL (18:45):
There was another one had me sitting...standing in a screen with waders on.
GN (18:50):
Yeah, I mean that kind of on touch screens with different way of looking at the school. It was a real
learning kind of thing you hear and what are you doing so. So I always kind of impressed with that. But I
was wondering, what will you attribute to be the evidence that made this? What made them decide to
take it seriously, to make this a major?
Tom Lynch (19:13):
Well, I think it all goes back to the 1970s. So you had the first earth day was I think 1970 and then you
had...so that whole earth day movement started and then in the meantime Congress and president
Nixon are passing the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, the Safe Water Drinking Act, Toxic Substances
Control Act and Dangerous Species Act. So, all this federal legislation got passed in the early to mid-
1970s. And so that created a lot of jobs and a lot of opportunities. And so that's why colleges I think
started to see, okay, well this is an area that we need to be generating some people who have got the
professional background.
GN (19:58):
The thing that affected me most to see it this way was that I guess one of the first moon shots are the
landing on the moon. They made the analogy of the capsule was like the earth, they had to survive in it
and everything was right there.
TL (20:15):
There's that famous photograph of the earth rising on the horizon of the moon, spaceship earth. That
whole idea. A number of articles came out about that time.
GN (20:27):
All we have is here, we have to save it.
TL (20:31):
This little blue planet in the vast ocean, dark ocean of space.
GN (20:35):
I have it on my wall, I know it well. How about the faculty now here?. Were you about the same in terms
of?
TL (20:45):
Yeah. So we've...over the 27 years I've been here, once we got past those first couple of years, we hired
Rich Feldman and we hired Zofia Gagnon and they're still here--Zofia just retired, Rich is still here. My
position has been replaced by a young guy who started about a year and a half ago. And they're going to
replace Zofia's position. Initially, from what I understand, temporarily for a year cause they just did
another five year review, that external reviewers come in that just within the last month or so. So they
want to get the input from those reviewers, see what suggestions they made, what kind of changes
might be needed in the program, et cetera. And then that'll determine what kind of specialty they're
looking for to replace Zofia.
GN (21:41):
How much does the administration play in...does Tom Wermuth play a big part in encouraging or...the
words I had in mind, there's notes here...did you have...was there resistance to the growth of the
program?
TL (21:58):
Well, I mean I always wanted some additional people in areas. I thought it would enhance the program if
we had somebody with a background in geology and hydrology. I thought that would really, as a fourth
faculty position, I thought-
GN (22:13):
Did you know Vincent Toscano?
TL (22:13):
I never...I've heard the name, Joe used to talk about him all the time, but I never...he was gone before I
came. But so, they said, well, you can build the program big enough, then we'll give you more faculty. So
it was that argument.
GN (22:30):
So it was chicken and the egg?
TL (22:30):
Right. Chicken and the egg kind of thing.
GN (22:32):
You mentioned the two aspects of it, the policy and the lab. What is the policy? What do you do there?
TL (22:41):
Well, it deals with things, and that was new. As I said, that was just starting when I started in '91. And so
that offered a track which had less science and more social science--environmental law, environmental
planning, in environmental politics. Basically, people would...who would go into working for...on the
legislative staff of people in Albany or we had...I added a number of people who served as interns to
United States senators and stuff like that as sort of their environmental--who advise them on
environmental policy kind of kind of things. So that...and then a number of them went into like
environmental planning with small to medium sized consulting firms specializing in planning,
environmental assessment, these kinds of things. Environmental law. A number of my students went to
law school for specializing environmental law.
GN (23:47):
Do you have much...do we take a course in environmental law?
TL (23:50):
Yeah, they do. Yeah. So policy people take a course in environmental law. And then they would take
courses from people like Martin Shaffer. He used to teach environmental politics and policy class.
Joanne Meyers used to teach an environmental planning class.
GN (24:11):
Yeah, she came out of the Albany...I did an interview with her one time when she was talking
about...she had come from Albany State, I guess Tim Harris. And the contrast, it was just this quaint kind
of a thing. Putting it practice, how do we get things done? You have to go to the legislature. You got to
influence those people to vote for it. How does Marist compare now with a typical...I don't know what
school I can take, Sienna just out of the blue, in terms of environmental sciences. Do you know how-?
TL (24:51):
I think we're as good as...I don't think we're as good as a Stanford or Cornell or a SUNY in environmental
science. I mean, SUNY has got a whole master's and graduate program, school of environmental science
in forestry E.S.N.F.
GN (25:08):
Which SUNY is this?
TL (25:10):
it's Syracuse, adjacent to the Syracuse campus. So they've got a school of environmental science in
forestry. So I don't think we're that good. We can't...we don't have the diversity of offerings. We don't
have the diversity of faculty. We don't have the graduate programs that they have.
GN (25:30):
Do we have any master's programs or are you going to go that route?
TL (25:33):
I'm sorry?
New Speaker (25:34):
Are there any master's programs in environment science?
TL (25:37):
No, not Marist.
GN (25:39):
Would you anticipate any?
TL (25:42):
We've talked about it from time to time, but again with two or three people-
GN (25:45):
Oh, yeah. You need numbers.
TL (25:45):
It's very hard to have a quality graduate program with just three faculty. But yeah, in terms of...you have
your Siennas and your Ionas, those kinds of schools, I think we're comparable.
GN (26:08):
We have the river anyway.
TL (26:09):
We have the river and that's something we haven't probably taken as much advantage of it as we could.
We've also got the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies over in Millbrook, so I know that we've been
strengthening the relationship with them over the last couple of years. I've certainly--over the years--I
put a lot of interns working for the scientists out there, both during academic years and during the
summer. They've hired some of our undergraduates after they've graduated. In fact, one of my earliest
students, did an internship out there, subsequently went to work out there for them full time for about
two years. Okay. Then went to graduate school and is now a full professor at Yale teaching
environmental science.
GN (27:06):
Of course 27 years ago, it makes him pretty old.
TL (27:09):
Yeah. So, he's got to be in his forties.
GN (27:12):
He's not a youngster.
TL (27:14):
So, he's got to be in his upper forties at this point.
GN (27:16):
Yeah. Again turning the page, let's call this the crystal ball. What do you see on the horizon or the future
for Marist? Let's say 10 years down the line, where do you see us? Are we going to be here?
TL (27:33):
Oh, I think we'll be here. I don't think there's any doubt about that. I mean, from what I...I haven't been
following it very closely for the last two years or so, but I mean my understanding is...in fact, I just heard
something the other day with the College of New Rochelle is closing as of this semester and Kent
Rinehart was being interviewed because Marist has apparently offered to take those students on as
transfer students.
GN (28:05):
It's not the first time we did that.
TL (28:07):
Cannibalizing...Mercy college was the other one, the other school that had offered to take on the
students who were still....who are going to be cut off, so sure. But they mentioned that during this
interview that we had 6,600 students here at Marist. So, I mean when I started it was probably 3000,
GN (28:29):
If that, yeah.
TL (28:30):
Something in that neighborhood, maybe a little bit less. And then, I mean certainly with the school of
science and they've got the graduate program now with the physician's assistant program.
GN (28:47):
Medical school coming.
TL (28:49):
And the medical school coming, if they can pull that off financially. And then they've got the doctorate in
physical therapy program, which just started back I think in September, June or whatever. So that'll
increase graduate type enrollment. Undergraduate, I don't really see in terms of science. I don't see
Marist growing much. I mean we're kind of facilities limited.
GN (29:16):
But there's also a drop in of candidates you can pull. I mean the population-
TL (29:21):
The population of high school students, but then there are these colleges that are falling by the wayside.
And I've heard Tom Wermuth just in the last couple of years mentioned, this school, that school lost its
accreditation; this looks folding, et cetera. So there's probably going to be some attrition among these
smaller colleges that Marist may be able to cannibalize some of their student body.
GN (29:48):
[Laughter] I understand very well, and it's true. I mean, we're looking for those candidates and so the
development matters. Look at the dollars we just put up. Sure. I mean it's quite a difference to the ones
I knew.
TL (30:06):
And going back to your question though, I mean in terms of growth in the school of science, I don't see
that because again, I just heard, I think Kathy Newkirk told me about two weeks ago that when the new
building was built across the street, the idea was that within 10 years there was going to be a second
science building constructed adjacent to it with a bridge. Well, she said all of a sudden that second
science building is not anywhere in the 10-year plan. So right now the undergraduate offices, labs and
stuff are maxed out. Unless they opened up more room in Donnelley.
GN (30:50):
What are they going to do with fashion design?
TL (30:53):
Well, fashion design is supposed to be moving over into-
GN (30:54):
It has, yeah.
TL (30:54):
So maybe that space, we'll get some of that space. Who knows?
GN (31:01):
But in this development age, how about off-campus learning? The online stuff, do you see that as part of
it?
TL (31:13):
Oh, I know certain...I don't think that's ever been looked at very favorably by people in the sciences. I
mean we've always kind of been dragged kicking and screaming in that direction. We do offer a couple
of undergraduate courses for non-majors, like Introduction to Environmental Science, both during the
academic year as well as during the summer. So that you could probably do because that doesn't
require any laboratory work and it doesn't necessarily require any field work. So that you could probably
do online. But you know, how are you going to teach physiology or how are you going to teach
comparative anatomy? Or how are you going to teach chemistry online? I mean, you have to have that
hands on experience to do that. And so yeah, we've never--as a science faculty--we've never sort of
been too enthusiastic about the idea of going...offering a lot of online courses despite constantly being
encouraged by Dennis. Oh you guys need to do this, you guys need to do this. We kind of guessed him to
death.
GN (32:27):
[Laughter] Been there. I mean the enrollment at Marist--for what it is--has ultimately become much
widespread. We have a map upstairs about the USA where people have from.
TL (32:43):
I think it's diversified there a lot, outside of the three state region.
GN (32:48):
Oh yeah. We used to be just Long Island. There was only one place...people going to the island, there
was only one like Manhattan. Long Island was going to be it, you know. Now I mean, I think we got 90
students from California.
TL (33:04):
I know California, in the last few years, they've made a big push because I used to have some of those
non-majors in class.
GN (33:11):
Well, we sent a football team out there every other year to let them know we're here. So that's it. On
this crystal ball, if you had a chance or invited to go to board of trustees to represent environmental
science because you're experienced, what would you say?
TL (33:35):
Well, I guess part of this goes back to one of my last efforts as a full time faculty member. I'm trying to
get, I mean for quite a number of years, I served on the campus sustainability committee and with Steve
Sansola and stuff like that. And we picked a lot of low hanging fruit in terms of getting environmental
and getting Marist to be greener in terms of its practices and policies and stuff like that. But we always
avoided making the tougher calls. And so one of the last things I did in the last year and a half I was
here, was a group of six of us came and wrote up a white paper dealing with climate change and how
from an ethical and economic and from a scientific standpoint--so we've made three arguments...ethics,
tying it into our mission statement. How as an institution we should be responding to the global threat
of climate change. We made an economic, and so what we were trying to do is get Marist to consider
divesting its investments from fossil fuel companies. And then we made the scientific arguments. So it
was a fairly considerable length white paper. We presented it to the faculty. Faculty approved it by a
two to one vote. 66% to 33% or whatever to forward it to the trustees. So we made...we had like 12, 10
or 12 recommendations as to how--as an institution--Marist could be greener, more ethically
responsible in terms of responding to climate change in terms of changing their practice.
GN (35:37):
So you believe in climate change? It's a reality?
TL (35:39):
Oh, absolutely. Yeah, totally convinced. In fact, just before I met you, I was sitting in the library here
reading an article in Scientific America about the melting of...some of the Antarctic glaciers, how it's
accelerating. Anyway. So, they took over a year to respond to this white paper because of... and they
basically said, well, in terms of our role is if I do share your responsibility to the institution, this is going
to cost too much. We can't implement these changes. Thank you very much for the recommendations.
And so, we've got a few green roofs on a couple of buildings, but we're still buying all our fuel from
natural gas or our electricity is all coming from fossil fuel fire-powered plants. And so those were the
kinds of things we wanted to see Marist kind of shift. And so I think, I ultimately...I think climate change-
-well, a couple of different things--climate change I think is probably the biggest immediate threat to our
future generations. I worry, I mean, I've got five grandchildren at this point. The oldest one is eight. And
so conceivably, they're going to live to 2100. And so I said to my wife the night of the...when the first
one was being born, she said, you don't seem too enthusiastic that we're going to have our first
grandchild by tomorrow morning because my daughter was having a C-section and I said, I feel sorry for
the kid. I said, I'm thrilled. I'm going to have my first grandson, but I feel sorry for the kid. I said because
of just half the stuff that I tell my class in predictions like environmental issues, just half of those
predictions come true. They're in for a really, really bumpy road in terms of climate change and air
pollution, water pollution and acidification of the oceans and population growth, food shortages, water
scarcity. I mean the list just goes on and on. Loss of biodiversity and rising sea levels and flood. I mean
it's just horrendous. And so I still...I mean I'm still very pessimistic in terms of the life that my
grandchildren are going to have to cope with because of all this stuff that's happening and it's all coming
together.
GN (38:17):
What's the condition of the Hudson?
TL (38:20):
The Hudson is actually in pretty decent shape. I mean there's some problems with it in terms of
chemical contamination. There's a lot of invasive species, but I mean the system is just going to have to
adjust to those but...so it's a lot better than it was 30 years ago.
GN (38:42):
When you came here, it was-?
TL (38:44):
Well, in fact, I had a conversation with...I used to spend a lot of time down at that lab attached to the
Cornell Boathouse. And so I got to know some of the crew coaches and stuff like that. And one of them
said that, he said that he had been crew coach for 20-something years. And he said, when I first started
doing crew, he said every crew member before they got out of the river had to be vaccinated for
hepatitis. And he said, we would see toilet papers and condoms and fecal matter and everything else
out in the water. So he said they all had to be vaccinated for hepatitis.
GN (39:19):
Was there a sewer leakage or something?
TL (39:21):
It used to just be dumped, raw sewage. So all that started changing in the 1970s but it took a long time
for sewage treatment plants to be built, upgraded, this kind of stuff. So he said--the other thing has
changed--he said once the oars went in the water, he said we couldn't even--he said, they're only that
far down--but he said we couldn't see them and therefore we didn't know whether they were holding at
the right angle or not. He said 'the water is now clarified,' and he said, now when the oars go down, we
can tell that the crew team whether they're holding the oars in the right position. So he said he had seen
a significant change and he said back then, the coxswain if they won the race didn't want to be thrown
in the river--which was tradition--because it was so filthy. So yeah, the Hudson is significantly improved.
I mean, there are still some threats to it, but-
GN (40:18):
I think the thing that amazes me is the rise of the ocean and what...so many cities along the...Miami will
be typical.
TL (40:26):
Miami is flooding once a month. Miami Beach is flooding every month on full moon. And so their
solution is they're simply building the roads higher. So they're raising all the roads two or three feet, but
now all the businesses which were along the road are down below the road so they haven't...so they've
solved the transportation problem temporarily. But...and they're still building like crazy down in Florida.
I mean there are just all kinds of high rise apartments and condos and stuff going up all over the place in
South Florida. I mean, I was just down there for two months. I saw a lot of it, they're just building like
this isn't a problem.
GN (41:07):
Well, turn the page again to something else, what do you think...what are your happiest moments here?
What are some of the best achievements that you...you had that student who went to Yale for one.
What do you-?
TL (41:26):
Well, I guess the thing that comes immediately to mind is that when I retired from full-time before I
went into the two-year step down, I...the school threw a little get together at lunch. They said to me, 'do
you want a going away party? I said I don't know if I do, I'm not really into it. But they did it anyway. And
so what--and I'll all always be grateful to him for this--Rich Feldman went out and he contacted all of our
previous graduates back to the time that I started and he asked them to-
GN (42:04):
Send a note?
TL (42:05):
Send in a note or whatever. So, I mean, I got...so there was like maybe a 100, 110 students that had
graduated at that point. And I got...I don't know something in the neighborhood of 35 or 36 responses
from my former students telling me what a great influence I had been in their life, and a role model. So I
mean that was, I mean I had to...and he compiled them all together into a book and handed it to me at
this reception. And I couldn't read it all in one setting. I mean, it was just too emotional. I had to take in
pieces. And so yeah, obviously I've made a difference in the lives of some students and-
GN (42:57):
And in the institution. I mean, I just know from being here. So that leads me to this next question, which
kind of will be answered different ways by different people. What...is Marist worth the investment for
the student? And by that I mean, if you look at it--there's a financial, there's a time to study and so on.
There's a social one in terms of leaving home and breaking in to new things. And the commitment to,
you know...you put all this in and is it worth it? Could you...I know my cousin, while he
wouldn't...because my niece's husband is a well-to-do--he's doing well on Wall Street. He has a boy
graduating from high school and he said he could just as well buy him a franchise, and financially he
would be as better off than going to college. So-
TL (43:59):
That may very well be true in terms of finance. In terms of finances that may very well may be true. I
mean, because, first of all, I don't think college is for everybody. In fact, I think there's a lot of students
here who probably shouldn't be here. That they're here-
GN (44:19):
We need carpenters and plumbers.
TL (44:22):
And that's exactly right, and that's my point. You know, that we need those kinds of people. You can
make a very good living as one of those tradespeople owning your own business, et cetera. So, do you
need to go to college? I don't think you do. And in many cases, they're probably making more than
faculty members are making here in terms of their livelihoods and stuff like that. So, I don't think you
should come to college because your parents expect you to come to college. I think--and I've always said
this--is I think that most high school students come to college two years too soon than they should.
There should be a two year hiatus where they go into the military or they go into, Peace Corps or just go
sling burgers at McDonald's and get your head on straight and figure out what your priorities are, and
then make up your mind that this is what you want to do. Because again, a lot of them are just kind of
going through the motions and-
GN (45:34):
They're maturing here, but while they're playing at it they're wasting some time.
TL (45:38):
Right. Yeah. And this, and if you're doing it for that reason, okay. That's a very expensive way to make a
decision, just kind of bite your time and try to take the four years to figure out what you want to do. I
had two nephews, they both went to state schools. One went to University of Connecticut and one we
went over here to SUNY New Paltz. They both got good educations. They're both well employed.
GN (46:15):
Happy?
TL (46:16):
Yeah. One's working, one's went and got his MBA and now his CPA. He's working for a big firm
down...one of the major five accounting firms and seems...living down in the city and things seems really
happy. The other majored over here in New Paltz in history and he's got himself a nice job teaching
history at a high school down in Queens and seems very happy. And so...but I think it all depends on the
kind of school you go to, I think. When I went to University of Bridgeport and at that time there were
about 4,000 undergraduates. Roughly the size of mirrors. When I went for my PhD at Michigan State,
there were 45,000 students. The freshmen class was 10,000 students. And I mean, you could tell, I
mean, these kids were shell-shocked for months. I mean, they just had this glazed look in your eye and
you can pick them off the sidewalk. There's a freshmen, there's, I mean, just by this glaze look in their
eye...so I mean, they were living in 17-story dormitories and stuff like that. And you know, their classes
were in the hundreds students, if not-
GN (47:31):
I like to throw out a, I just,
TL (47:33):
Well, and I took...one of the courses they wanted me to take, they said, well, you need to have some
programming. So they made me take a Fortran programming course. There were 1200 students in the
class meeting at the same time; everybody met the same time, the same day, but we met in 12 different
locations. And the instructor was on a TV screen. so 1200 students sitting, watching 12 different screens
with a graduate student who was given five minutes at the end of the class to answer any questions you
might have. So as an undergraduate, would I have thrived in that kind of environment? No way. So I
mean, I was a biology major at the University of Bridgeport. I was in a class of like 30-35 most of the
time. And we traveled together the whole four years. So we were in the same chemistry class, same
biology classes, et cetera. So yeah, it was a small group that basically traveled together through the four
years. And so I think smaller is better.
GN (48:35):
I was totally impressed here at Marist you guys in the science had your labs...Bettencourt was in there
from morning till night, weekends included, you know. And I say, that kind of contact, which leads to
my-
TL (48:48):
Which you wouldn't get at a much bigger school.
GN (48:50):
Right.
TL (48:52):
Or it would be a graduate student-
GN (48:54):
Working with you.
TL (48:58):
Yeah, and even they would limit their time because teaching was not their primary responsibility or
interest. They were just doing it for their financial support, their assistantships.
GN (49:11):
Lastly, why did you stay here so long?
TL (49:15):
Well I mean I like to say I liked the people. I liked the campus. So I mean-
GN (49:27):
You weren't very well paid. You were paid but not-
TL (49:30):
Well, I was paid maybe comparably to what I was making out in New Mexico. It was higher, but the cost
of living is higher here, so taxes are higher here than they were in New Mexico. So on face value it looks
like I was making more money than I probably was making in terms of actual spending power, I probably
wasn't making any more or any less than that out there. But all my family were back in this area. My
wife and I were the only two that sort of wandered off, and I'd been gone for 17 years basically. And our
parents were still...all of our parents were still alive, but getting older and so, okay this isn't going to last
forever. So yeah, it was, it was a mix of family, location. I mean, I'm a fisherman, so I mean I had the
Hudson River and all these fly fishing opportunities all around. The people, I mean Marist was very
welcoming when I came. We used to sit and--like you said--we used to sit around at lunch time in
Donnelley Hall. Everybody was on the same schedule. We all had that lunch hour free. You and Liz and
Andy and Rosemary and Cecily and Mark VanderHeyden and Richard LaPietra and Joe-
GN (50:54):
People going up to the board to explain certain things.
TL (50:54):
Yeah. Lynne Doty, Judith Saunders. All the different people who used to wander in and out during-
GN (50:59):
But now I understand you can't have lunch in the lab anymore. They took...see you environmentalists-
TL (51:04):
Well then as soon as they...as soon as Mark VanderHeyden changed the schedule to the present
schedule, now everybody was on a different lunch. There wasn't a common lunch hour anymore. So
then that all just kind of faded away, people started eating at their desk or whatever. And so all that was
kind of lost, which I think is a shame. The other problem I see with the school of science is--and I knew
this was going to happen and Kathy Newkirk confirmed it for me just the other day--is they've split the
school between two locations at this point. So they've got the biology department and they've got the
athletic training people over in the new science building. They've got chemistry and environmental
science over in Donnelley, and very rarely do those two groups ever get together. And so as time goes
by, you're just going to see a-
GN (52:02):
A demise?
TL (52:02):
Well not...I mean just people drifting away. You know, you don't...new faculty are coming in, old faculty
are leaving, the people who are in one building don't get to know the people in the other building the
way we did when everybody sat around the table every day, five days a week having lunch together. So I
think that's a negative as a result of the growth.
GN (52:27):
Is there a consistency though in the Marist spirit as such? I mean, people are welcoming by and large. I
sense that among the students that there's a basic simplicity. They still hold a door for you, which is-
TL (52:44):
Right. And my wife, she used to work in student services over at Vassar college. And so I had
opportunities to be on the Vassar campus on numerous occasions. And you could tell. I mean, it's just a
different culture. It's a different student body. I mean, just from the way they dress-- tattoos, body
piercings. Political activity, social consciousness. So in some respects Marists students are a little bit less-
GN (53:26):
Avant Garde? [Chuckles]
TL (53:26):
Well, they're a little bit less active, a little bit less outspoken, a little bit less politically involved on social
issues and stuff then something like a Bard or Vassar. So you could tell...if you put a Marist student and
a Vassar student, if you picked 10 and 10, say which one is which, I predict I could probably...eight out of
10, I could pick them, I can peg them as to which campus they had come from. So yeah, so...but I mean,
like you say, I mean Marist students, I mean they've always been really nice kids. Very polite, very
respectful.
GN (54:12):
Yeah. I think they draw each other too. I mean, there's a magnet. They want to bring like unto like.
TL (54:20):
And I think they tend to help each other studying, at least in the sciences. I mean forming study groups
and working together and looking out for each other and stuff like that, so.
GN (54:35):
Good. I've said everything I wanted to say. Is there something you'd like to say in closing of this?
TL (54:41):
I think we've covered a lot of ground.
GN (54:43):
We did. And so with that, thank you very much Tom, it's been a real pleasure.
TL (54:47):
Yeah. Thank you.
Marist College
Poughkeepsie, NY
Transcribed by Kyra Walker
For the Marist College Archives and Special Collections
Thomas Lynch
Transcript – Thomas Lynch
Interviewee:
Thomas Lynch
Interviewer:
Gus Nolan
Interview Date:
26 March 2019
Location:
Marist Archives and Special Collections
Topic:
Marist College History
Subject Headings:
Lynch, Thomas
Marist Brothers—United States—History
Marist College—History
Marist College (Poughkeepsie, N.Y.)
Marist College—Environmental Science
Summary:
Tom Lynch provides insight to his background as a professor in environmental science. He
reflects on the growth of the environmental science department at Marist, and the changes that
that college and its students has undergone throughout the years.
Gus Nolan (00:02):
Today is Tuesday, the 26th of March. Now we have the opportunity to interview a retired professor,
Tom Lynch from the environmental sciences. Good Afternoon Tom.
Tom Lynch (01:06):
Good Afternoon Gus, glad to be here.
GN (01:08):
Thank you. I wonder, we're going to start by kind of a general overview. Kind of a thumbnail overview of
your life, your early years, where you grew up and kind of give us an idea of where you're coming from.
TL (01:25):
Okay.
GN (01:26):
So where would you say, born in the eastern United States? You can give me more detail.
TL (01:31):
I was born in Bridgeport, Connecticut--lived there, went to Catholic elementary school, Catholic high
school. I went to the University of Bridgeport where I got bachelors and master's degrees in biology. I
taught high school science in Monroe, Connecticut for two years. And then I decided to go back for my
PhD degree in aquatic ecology with the fisheries and wildlife department at Michigan State University.
So I spent five years living in Michigan getting my...working on my PhD. And then my first job was with a
biology department out in the Southwest in a little town called Socorro, New Mexico.
GN (02:17):
Okay. Before we get into the professional, more things about the growing up. Special interests...you
seem to ban outdoorsman, so were you involved in sports as well?
TL (02:29):
I didn't get involved in the organized sports growing up. At that time, every kid...every house on the
block had three, four, or five kids. And so we played a lot of sandlot kind of stuff--baseball, football,
basketball, et cetera. It was very easy to put together two teams because like I say, everybody
had...every house had multiple kids, back in the middle of the baby boom there. And we used to spend a
lot of time outdoors. I mean where I grew up, it was a suburban area of Bridgeport and at the time it
was hundreds of acres of open space just down the street from us. And so we used to play Cowboys and
Indians and soldiers and we used to hunt and we used to sneak over to a private lake, which was maybe
300.
GN (03:29):
Alright, I didn't want to go there [laughter].
TL (03:31):
Well, one side was developed, the other side was not developed. So we used to sneak around to the
undeveloped side and fish and camp and stuff like that.
GN (03:41):
How about particular interests in your personal life. Talents...music or reading or a hobby and stamps
collection or anything like that?
TL (03:54):
Yeah, I did stamp collecting for a while when I was, I don't know, probably middle school age because
my grandfather had done it, so my father gave me some of my grandfather's stamp books. But I kind of
lost interest in that. And so I spent a lot of time reading. Like I say, a lot of times outdoors we would
come home from school and of course we always wore uniforms. So we very quickly change and you're
out the door until dinner time. And same thing on weekends, eight or nine o'clock in the morning, we
were gone, we'd show up for supper.
GN (04:33):
How big is the family of which you speak now?
TL (04:35):
I had three brothers and one sister. One brother is now deceased, the others are...the other siblings are
still alive. Two of them live over in the Bridgeport, Connecticut area. One lives in North Carolina. So-
GN (04:55):
Okay. Changing pace a little bit, what's the genesis of your coming to Marist? How did that happen?
TL (05:00):
Well, when I was working out in...well, I went to a Marist Brothers high school.
GN (05:05):
Where?
TL (05:05):
In Trumbull, Connecticut. So St. Joseph's High School. And so I was familiar with the Marist Brothers. My
older brother who's now deceased, he actually went into the Marist Brothers and spent one year in tins
Bureau. So he spent one year there and then left. And so I was familiar with the Marist Brothers and I
had heard of Marist College because of all the brothers. We had us as high school faculty. So then
I...after I finished my PhD degree, I...my first teaching job was at a school of science and engineering in
New Mexico, in the biology department. So I spent 12 years out there, eventually becoming department
chair. And then I saw an ad in the...this weekly journal called Science. You're looking for somebody to
teach environmental science at Marist College. And so I said my wife--who's from Yonkers--I said, should
I apply for it? Because when we initially moved out to this town, it was only town of 6,500. She said, I'll
give you two years and we're out of here. Because we were...being, she's from Yonkers, I'm from-
GN (06:23):
Your family is up here anyway.
TL (06:24):
Yeah, family was all here and just the whole...the greenery and stuff like that...the Southwest is just
brown and very different and a little wine vegetation. And the town was really small, 6,500. So, when
she took his first look at it, she saw I'd give you two years and we're out of here. Well, two years turned
into 12. And then...and so we have a lot of really good friends and stuff there. And so when I saw this ad
for Marist, and I had been developing an environmental science program at the Mexico Institute of
Mining and Technology. And so I said, well, should I apply for it? She said yeah, what have you got to
lose? So I applied for it. I came, I interviewed.
GN (07:09):
About what year was this?
TL (07:09):
This was in '91.
GN (07:12):
'91. So Dennis has in place as well?
TL (07:16):
Yeah, Dennis was already here. Andy Malloy was a chair of the department, or chair--I guess it wasn't
even a department yet--chair of the school of sciences, is what it was called. And so I interviewed, and
then Andy offered me the position. And so then-
GN (07:38):
Did you come as a biologist?
TL (07:39):
I came as an...they were recruiting for a director of the environmental science program. So I came in as
an associate professor because I was already tenured out at this other school and actually had just
gotten promoted to full professor. And so I came in with all my degrees are in basically biology. But they
hired me as the director of the environmental science program. And so-
GN (08:16):
Well let's just talk about Marist for a minute. In '91, certainly we've changed considerably since that day.
What would you say about that? What will you attribute or where do you see the biggest change in
Marist from '91 to-
TL (08:33):
Obviously just in size and the physical plant and stuff like that. I mean, I was reflecting on...anticipating
you probably asking that type of question. And so I think, I can't remember how many faculty there
were when I came. I know we all fit during plenaries into Donnelley 225 and within a couple of years I
think I probably pretty much knew everybody in the room.
GN (09:00):
Not for lunch where they had biology labs. Bill Pear was in there.
TL (09:06):
So we used to do, yeah. So Bill Pear died several weeks after I got here, so I only knew him for a couple
of weeks. Because we were in the same office suite together. So it was Bill and Andy and myself and
Vicky Ingalls. And Betty Jaycox was our secretary at the time.
GN (09:26):
Was LaPietra on the scene yet?
TL (09:28):
Richard LaPietra was here. Matt Polusny was here. Larry Menapace was here.
GN (09:35):
Was Richard in chemistry?
TL (09:37):
Richard was in chemistry. Richard, Andy Matt Polusny, and Larry Menapace were all in the chemistry
department.
GN (09:44):
Okay, and Bettencourt was in biology?
TL (09:46):
Bettencourt was in biology. Vicky Ingalls was in biology.
GN (09:54):
All right. I just...I'm trying to get historical things. Just comment this now in terms of Marist and its
growth and development. What was you think the greatest input for that? Was it Dennis or was it the
tradition or was it the student body or is the potential, where was going? How do you explain?
TL (10:15):
Oh, it's probably a combination of all of those things. I mean, Dennis certainly had his vision, although I
often didn't agree with the direction that he was taking the college fashionably in terms of the changes
that he was requiring of the faculty and stuff like that. And our priorities and those kinds of things. But I
think the reputation of the college kind of gradually grew and then certainly as we became larger, we've
got number of different programs. So even environmental science, I mean when I initially came, I was
the only person in environmental science and within three or four years we had hired Rich Feldman.
GN (11:07):
Okay, I want to get into that. But before that I want you to talk about...has there been a drastic change
in the student body in terms of anything? Is their spirit the same, their capabilities the same, their
backgrounds the same?
TL (11:24):
I mean I've taught...obviously I've taught a lot of the majors. I don't think the majors have changed all
that. The environmental science and policy majors, I don't think they've changed all that much. I think
they're probably comparable, maybe slightly better quality. But in terms of the of the non-majors,
because I taught a lot of those, because I used to teach introduction to environmental issues, probably
taught that course 60 plus times over the 27 years I was here. But I think there are a lot of those...or a
lot of the attitude of those...I mean, I think that writing has deteriorated. The ability to write as
deteriorated. The ability to do work outside of class I think has degenerated.
GN (12:17):
Really?
TL (12:18):
That was just my impression, particularly among the non-majors. There was a lot more, again from
my...we've had discussions about this with Vicky and Joe and whatever that the students now require a
lot more spoon-feeding. They want extra help sessions, they want review sheets.
GN (12:41):
Well, part of that I guess is also what you talked about you when you grew up, the families were five and
six, and now they're two and three, so parents are helicopting over-
TL (12:52):
They can get much more helicoptering parents. Certainly, whatever that education--I forget what the
name of it, where you can't talk to the parents without permission from the school. The Educational
Rights and Privacy Act, I guess.
GN (13:11):
Well, you can't send the grades to them.
TL (13:12):
You can't send the grades to me. You can't post grades anymore. So we used to just post grades by
social security number or student number, that kind of thing. You can't do that anymore. So a lot of that
has changed. And I think the students have just gotten more of an attitude of...I'm not sure what the
word I'm looking for. I used to lay it out with my students--particularly the non-majors--I said that the
average grade in this class, at the end of the course, it's going to be probably a C or C plus. And I--vividly-
-I remember one young lady sitting right in front of me and she's like, what do you mean the average is
going to be C plus. And I said, well we can't all be above average. A is above average, it's exceptional.
This is a link we'll be going where everybody's above average.
GN (14:12):
They call me C ++.
TL (14:12):
So I said, there's going to be A's, there's going to be F's. And I said, I've got no high expectations. I've
got...I'm pretty well calibrated. I'm happy to give you an A if you earn it, but I'm not going to...so there
was just more of a... I think in particular more in the last probably 10 or 15 years more of an attitude
that we're paying a lot of money for this education. You need to-
GN (14:40):
We deserve something from it.
TL (14:40):
You need to give us a good grade for the money that we're paying here.
GN (14:44):
Moreover, we write reports on you.
TL (14:48):
Yeah.
GN (14:50):
Changing the page to another issue, about environmental science--this was not a subject that I knew
about in college. We never talked about this.
TL (15:00):
Well, and when I was an undergraduate, it was never offered either. So Marist...so one of the first things
I had to do when I came, was Andy said, you need to do a program review. And so I had to delve into all
the records, enrollments and all this kind of stuff. So I was able to trace the environmental science
program back here to about 1974.
GN (15:27):
Really?
TL (15:28):
And then...so that would make it probably one of the oldest environmental science programs in four
year colleges because I mean, I graduated as an undergraduate in '71 and there were no colleges
offering environmental science programs at that point. And they really...the environmental science as a
separate discipline, or really as an interdisciplinary approach really didn't...I would say start to pick up
until the mid-1980s/late 1980s. And that's when I started putting this program together out in New
Mexico. And so I had some familiarity with it. I had built or designed the curriculum and stuff, but it was
undergoing review, et cetera. So when I came here in '91, they had just...Brian Hill was my predecessor
and he had just revised the whole program into a three-track program. I actually was into a two-track
program, science and policy. And prior to that timing, enrollments have been really, really low. And so
when I started here, 45 freshmen came in with me, which is the highest I think we've ever hit. So the
word had gotten out, Harry Woods was spending a lot of time promoting it. He would take me out on
some of his tours on college nights and stuff like that. So from like '91 to about '95, we had some really,
really strong freshmen classes in terms of numbers. But about same time lots of other schools were
developing environmental science program. So when I did review in '91 there were about 400 colleges
that offered environmental science programs. By about 1996 when we had to do another review, that
number jumped up to over 800 and now it's probably closer to a thousand, so with the expansion of the
number of schools offering the programs now the students were interested had double the number of
colleges to pick from. So our enrollment started a long slide starting. So we were...at one point, we were
at like 105 or 110 majors over the last probably 18 years. We probably in the neighborhood of 50 or 60
and we've never been able to push it up. We've never gotten below that. But you know, so over the last
15-18 years, we've been at a steady mid-fifties in terms of enrollment, never the kind of enrollment we
have from like '91 to '95.
GN (18:29):
But we've achieved that there's more opportunities now. I mean I always want to be interested. We had
one of the college magazines had you on the cover to vote the lab-
TL (18:45):
There was another one had me sitting...standing in a screen with waders on.
GN (18:50):
Yeah, I mean that kind of on touch screens with different way of looking at the school. It was a real
learning kind of thing you hear and what are you doing so. So I always kind of impressed with that. But I
was wondering, what will you attribute to be the evidence that made this? What made them decide to
take it seriously, to make this a major?
Tom Lynch (19:13):
Well, I think it all goes back to the 1970s. So you had the first earth day was I think 1970 and then you
had...so that whole earth day movement started and then in the meantime Congress and president
Nixon are passing the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, the Safe Water Drinking Act, Toxic Substances
Control Act and Dangerous Species Act. So, all this federal legislation got passed in the early to mid-
1970s. And so that created a lot of jobs and a lot of opportunities. And so that's why colleges I think
started to see, okay, well this is an area that we need to be generating some people who have got the
professional background.
GN (19:58):
The thing that affected me most to see it this way was that I guess one of the first moon shots are the
landing on the moon. They made the analogy of the capsule was like the earth, they had to survive in it
and everything was right there.
TL (20:15):
There's that famous photograph of the earth rising on the horizon of the moon, spaceship earth. That
whole idea. A number of articles came out about that time.
GN (20:27):
All we have is here, we have to save it.
TL (20:31):
This little blue planet in the vast ocean, dark ocean of space.
GN (20:35):
I have it on my wall, I know it well. How about the faculty now here?. Were you about the same in terms
of?
TL (20:45):
Yeah. So we've...over the 27 years I've been here, once we got past those first couple of years, we hired
Rich Feldman and we hired Zofia Gagnon and they're still here--Zofia just retired, Rich is still here. My
position has been replaced by a young guy who started about a year and a half ago. And they're going to
replace Zofia's position. Initially, from what I understand, temporarily for a year cause they just did
another five year review, that external reviewers come in that just within the last month or so. So they
want to get the input from those reviewers, see what suggestions they made, what kind of changes
might be needed in the program, et cetera. And then that'll determine what kind of specialty they're
looking for to replace Zofia.
GN (21:41):
How much does the administration play in...does Tom Wermuth play a big part in encouraging or...the
words I had in mind, there's notes here...did you have...was there resistance to the growth of the
program?
TL (21:58):
Well, I mean I always wanted some additional people in areas. I thought it would enhance the program if
we had somebody with a background in geology and hydrology. I thought that would really, as a fourth
faculty position, I thought-
GN (22:13):
Did you know Vincent Toscano?
TL (22:13):
I never...I've heard the name, Joe used to talk about him all the time, but I never...he was gone before I
came. But so, they said, well, you can build the program big enough, then we'll give you more faculty. So
it was that argument.
GN (22:30):
So it was chicken and the egg?
TL (22:30):
Right. Chicken and the egg kind of thing.
GN (22:32):
You mentioned the two aspects of it, the policy and the lab. What is the policy? What do you do there?
TL (22:41):
Well, it deals with things, and that was new. As I said, that was just starting when I started in '91. And so
that offered a track which had less science and more social science--environmental law, environmental
planning, in environmental politics. Basically, people would...who would go into working for...on the
legislative staff of people in Albany or we had...I added a number of people who served as interns to
United States senators and stuff like that as sort of their environmental--who advise them on
environmental policy kind of kind of things. So that...and then a number of them went into like
environmental planning with small to medium sized consulting firms specializing in planning,
environmental assessment, these kinds of things. Environmental law. A number of my students went to
law school for specializing environmental law.
GN (23:47):
Do you have much...do we take a course in environmental law?
TL (23:50):
Yeah, they do. Yeah. So policy people take a course in environmental law. And then they would take
courses from people like Martin Shaffer. He used to teach environmental politics and policy class.
Joanne Meyers used to teach an environmental planning class.
GN (24:11):
Yeah, she came out of the Albany...I did an interview with her one time when she was talking
about...she had come from Albany State, I guess Tim Harris. And the contrast, it was just this quaint kind
of a thing. Putting it practice, how do we get things done? You have to go to the legislature. You got to
influence those people to vote for it. How does Marist compare now with a typical...I don't know what
school I can take, Sienna just out of the blue, in terms of environmental sciences. Do you know how-?
TL (24:51):
I think we're as good as...I don't think we're as good as a Stanford or Cornell or a SUNY in environmental
science. I mean, SUNY has got a whole master's and graduate program, school of environmental science
in forestry E.S.N.F.
GN (25:08):
Which SUNY is this?
TL (25:10):
it's Syracuse, adjacent to the Syracuse campus. So they've got a school of environmental science in
forestry. So I don't think we're that good. We can't...we don't have the diversity of offerings. We don't
have the diversity of faculty. We don't have the graduate programs that they have.
GN (25:30):
Do we have any master's programs or are you going to go that route?
TL (25:33):
I'm sorry?
New Speaker (25:34):
Are there any master's programs in environment science?
TL (25:37):
No, not Marist.
GN (25:39):
Would you anticipate any?
TL (25:42):
We've talked about it from time to time, but again with two or three people-
GN (25:45):
Oh, yeah. You need numbers.
TL (25:45):
It's very hard to have a quality graduate program with just three faculty. But yeah, in terms of...you have
your Siennas and your Ionas, those kinds of schools, I think we're comparable.
GN (26:08):
We have the river anyway.
TL (26:09):
We have the river and that's something we haven't probably taken as much advantage of it as we could.
We've also got the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies over in Millbrook, so I know that we've been
strengthening the relationship with them over the last couple of years. I've certainly--over the years--I
put a lot of interns working for the scientists out there, both during academic years and during the
summer. They've hired some of our undergraduates after they've graduated. In fact, one of my earliest
students, did an internship out there, subsequently went to work out there for them full time for about
two years. Okay. Then went to graduate school and is now a full professor at Yale teaching
environmental science.
GN (27:06):
Of course 27 years ago, it makes him pretty old.
TL (27:09):
Yeah. So, he's got to be in his forties.
GN (27:12):
He's not a youngster.
TL (27:14):
So, he's got to be in his upper forties at this point.
GN (27:16):
Yeah. Again turning the page, let's call this the crystal ball. What do you see on the horizon or the future
for Marist? Let's say 10 years down the line, where do you see us? Are we going to be here?
TL (27:33):
Oh, I think we'll be here. I don't think there's any doubt about that. I mean, from what I...I haven't been
following it very closely for the last two years or so, but I mean my understanding is...in fact, I just heard
something the other day with the College of New Rochelle is closing as of this semester and Kent
Rinehart was being interviewed because Marist has apparently offered to take those students on as
transfer students.
GN (28:05):
It's not the first time we did that.
TL (28:07):
Cannibalizing...Mercy college was the other one, the other school that had offered to take on the
students who were still....who are going to be cut off, so sure. But they mentioned that during this
interview that we had 6,600 students here at Marist. So, I mean when I started it was probably 3000,
GN (28:29):
If that, yeah.
TL (28:30):
Something in that neighborhood, maybe a little bit less. And then, I mean certainly with the school of
science and they've got the graduate program now with the physician's assistant program.
GN (28:47):
Medical school coming.
TL (28:49):
And the medical school coming, if they can pull that off financially. And then they've got the doctorate in
physical therapy program, which just started back I think in September, June or whatever. So that'll
increase graduate type enrollment. Undergraduate, I don't really see in terms of science. I don't see
Marist growing much. I mean we're kind of facilities limited.
GN (29:16):
But there's also a drop in of candidates you can pull. I mean the population-
TL (29:21):
The population of high school students, but then there are these colleges that are falling by the wayside.
And I've heard Tom Wermuth just in the last couple of years mentioned, this school, that school lost its
accreditation; this looks folding, et cetera. So there's probably going to be some attrition among these
smaller colleges that Marist may be able to cannibalize some of their student body.
GN (29:48):
[Laughter] I understand very well, and it's true. I mean, we're looking for those candidates and so the
development matters. Look at the dollars we just put up. Sure. I mean it's quite a difference to the ones
I knew.
TL (30:06):
And going back to your question though, I mean in terms of growth in the school of science, I don't see
that because again, I just heard, I think Kathy Newkirk told me about two weeks ago that when the new
building was built across the street, the idea was that within 10 years there was going to be a second
science building constructed adjacent to it with a bridge. Well, she said all of a sudden that second
science building is not anywhere in the 10-year plan. So right now the undergraduate offices, labs and
stuff are maxed out. Unless they opened up more room in Donnelley.
GN (30:50):
What are they going to do with fashion design?
TL (30:53):
Well, fashion design is supposed to be moving over into-
GN (30:54):
It has, yeah.
TL (30:54):
So maybe that space, we'll get some of that space. Who knows?
GN (31:01):
But in this development age, how about off-campus learning? The online stuff, do you see that as part of
it?
TL (31:13):
Oh, I know certain...I don't think that's ever been looked at very favorably by people in the sciences. I
mean we've always kind of been dragged kicking and screaming in that direction. We do offer a couple
of undergraduate courses for non-majors, like Introduction to Environmental Science, both during the
academic year as well as during the summer. So that you could probably do because that doesn't
require any laboratory work and it doesn't necessarily require any field work. So that you could probably
do online. But you know, how are you going to teach physiology or how are you going to teach
comparative anatomy? Or how are you going to teach chemistry online? I mean, you have to have that
hands on experience to do that. And so yeah, we've never--as a science faculty--we've never sort of
been too enthusiastic about the idea of going...offering a lot of online courses despite constantly being
encouraged by Dennis. Oh you guys need to do this, you guys need to do this. We kind of guessed him to
death.
GN (32:27):
[Laughter] Been there. I mean the enrollment at Marist--for what it is--has ultimately become much
widespread. We have a map upstairs about the USA where people have from.
TL (32:43):
I think it's diversified there a lot, outside of the three state region.
GN (32:48):
Oh yeah. We used to be just Long Island. There was only one place...people going to the island, there
was only one like Manhattan. Long Island was going to be it, you know. Now I mean, I think we got 90
students from California.
TL (33:04):
I know California, in the last few years, they've made a big push because I used to have some of those
non-majors in class.
GN (33:11):
Well, we sent a football team out there every other year to let them know we're here. So that's it. On
this crystal ball, if you had a chance or invited to go to board of trustees to represent environmental
science because you're experienced, what would you say?
TL (33:35):
Well, I guess part of this goes back to one of my last efforts as a full time faculty member. I'm trying to
get, I mean for quite a number of years, I served on the campus sustainability committee and with Steve
Sansola and stuff like that. And we picked a lot of low hanging fruit in terms of getting environmental
and getting Marist to be greener in terms of its practices and policies and stuff like that. But we always
avoided making the tougher calls. And so one of the last things I did in the last year and a half I was
here, was a group of six of us came and wrote up a white paper dealing with climate change and how
from an ethical and economic and from a scientific standpoint--so we've made three arguments...ethics,
tying it into our mission statement. How as an institution we should be responding to the global threat
of climate change. We made an economic, and so what we were trying to do is get Marist to consider
divesting its investments from fossil fuel companies. And then we made the scientific arguments. So it
was a fairly considerable length white paper. We presented it to the faculty. Faculty approved it by a
two to one vote. 66% to 33% or whatever to forward it to the trustees. So we made...we had like 12, 10
or 12 recommendations as to how--as an institution--Marist could be greener, more ethically
responsible in terms of responding to climate change in terms of changing their practice.
GN (35:37):
So you believe in climate change? It's a reality?
TL (35:39):
Oh, absolutely. Yeah, totally convinced. In fact, just before I met you, I was sitting in the library here
reading an article in Scientific America about the melting of...some of the Antarctic glaciers, how it's
accelerating. Anyway. So, they took over a year to respond to this white paper because of... and they
basically said, well, in terms of our role is if I do share your responsibility to the institution, this is going
to cost too much. We can't implement these changes. Thank you very much for the recommendations.
And so, we've got a few green roofs on a couple of buildings, but we're still buying all our fuel from
natural gas or our electricity is all coming from fossil fuel fire-powered plants. And so those were the
kinds of things we wanted to see Marist kind of shift. And so I think, I ultimately...I think climate change-
-well, a couple of different things--climate change I think is probably the biggest immediate threat to our
future generations. I worry, I mean, I've got five grandchildren at this point. The oldest one is eight. And
so conceivably, they're going to live to 2100. And so I said to my wife the night of the...when the first
one was being born, she said, you don't seem too enthusiastic that we're going to have our first
grandchild by tomorrow morning because my daughter was having a C-section and I said, I feel sorry for
the kid. I said, I'm thrilled. I'm going to have my first grandson, but I feel sorry for the kid. I said because
of just half the stuff that I tell my class in predictions like environmental issues, just half of those
predictions come true. They're in for a really, really bumpy road in terms of climate change and air
pollution, water pollution and acidification of the oceans and population growth, food shortages, water
scarcity. I mean the list just goes on and on. Loss of biodiversity and rising sea levels and flood. I mean
it's just horrendous. And so I still...I mean I'm still very pessimistic in terms of the life that my
grandchildren are going to have to cope with because of all this stuff that's happening and it's all coming
together.
GN (38:17):
What's the condition of the Hudson?
TL (38:20):
The Hudson is actually in pretty decent shape. I mean there's some problems with it in terms of
chemical contamination. There's a lot of invasive species, but I mean the system is just going to have to
adjust to those but...so it's a lot better than it was 30 years ago.
GN (38:42):
When you came here, it was-?
TL (38:44):
Well, in fact, I had a conversation with...I used to spend a lot of time down at that lab attached to the
Cornell Boathouse. And so I got to know some of the crew coaches and stuff like that. And one of them
said that, he said that he had been crew coach for 20-something years. And he said, when I first started
doing crew, he said every crew member before they got out of the river had to be vaccinated for
hepatitis. And he said, we would see toilet papers and condoms and fecal matter and everything else
out in the water. So he said they all had to be vaccinated for hepatitis.
GN (39:19):
Was there a sewer leakage or something?
TL (39:21):
It used to just be dumped, raw sewage. So all that started changing in the 1970s but it took a long time
for sewage treatment plants to be built, upgraded, this kind of stuff. So he said--the other thing has
changed--he said once the oars went in the water, he said we couldn't even--he said, they're only that
far down--but he said we couldn't see them and therefore we didn't know whether they were holding at
the right angle or not. He said 'the water is now clarified,' and he said, now when the oars go down, we
can tell that the crew team whether they're holding the oars in the right position. So he said he had seen
a significant change and he said back then, the coxswain if they won the race didn't want to be thrown
in the river--which was tradition--because it was so filthy. So yeah, the Hudson is significantly improved.
I mean, there are still some threats to it, but-
GN (40:18):
I think the thing that amazes me is the rise of the ocean and what...so many cities along the...Miami will
be typical.
TL (40:26):
Miami is flooding once a month. Miami Beach is flooding every month on full moon. And so their
solution is they're simply building the roads higher. So they're raising all the roads two or three feet, but
now all the businesses which were along the road are down below the road so they haven't...so they've
solved the transportation problem temporarily. But...and they're still building like crazy down in Florida.
I mean there are just all kinds of high rise apartments and condos and stuff going up all over the place in
South Florida. I mean, I was just down there for two months. I saw a lot of it, they're just building like
this isn't a problem.
GN (41:07):
Well, turn the page again to something else, what do you think...what are your happiest moments here?
What are some of the best achievements that you...you had that student who went to Yale for one.
What do you-?
TL (41:26):
Well, I guess the thing that comes immediately to mind is that when I retired from full-time before I
went into the two-year step down, I...the school threw a little get together at lunch. They said to me, 'do
you want a going away party? I said I don't know if I do, I'm not really into it. But they did it anyway. And
so what--and I'll all always be grateful to him for this--Rich Feldman went out and he contacted all of our
previous graduates back to the time that I started and he asked them to-
GN (42:04):
Send a note?
TL (42:05):
Send in a note or whatever. So, I mean, I got...so there was like maybe a 100, 110 students that had
graduated at that point. And I got...I don't know something in the neighborhood of 35 or 36 responses
from my former students telling me what a great influence I had been in their life, and a role model. So I
mean that was, I mean I had to...and he compiled them all together into a book and handed it to me at
this reception. And I couldn't read it all in one setting. I mean, it was just too emotional. I had to take in
pieces. And so yeah, obviously I've made a difference in the lives of some students and-
GN (42:57):
And in the institution. I mean, I just know from being here. So that leads me to this next question, which
kind of will be answered different ways by different people. What...is Marist worth the investment for
the student? And by that I mean, if you look at it--there's a financial, there's a time to study and so on.
There's a social one in terms of leaving home and breaking in to new things. And the commitment to,
you know...you put all this in and is it worth it? Could you...I know my cousin, while he
wouldn't...because my niece's husband is a well-to-do--he's doing well on Wall Street. He has a boy
graduating from high school and he said he could just as well buy him a franchise, and financially he
would be as better off than going to college. So-
TL (43:59):
That may very well be true in terms of finance. In terms of finances that may very well may be true. I
mean, because, first of all, I don't think college is for everybody. In fact, I think there's a lot of students
here who probably shouldn't be here. That they're here-
GN (44:19):
We need carpenters and plumbers.
TL (44:22):
And that's exactly right, and that's my point. You know, that we need those kinds of people. You can
make a very good living as one of those tradespeople owning your own business, et cetera. So, do you
need to go to college? I don't think you do. And in many cases, they're probably making more than
faculty members are making here in terms of their livelihoods and stuff like that. So, I don't think you
should come to college because your parents expect you to come to college. I think--and I've always said
this--is I think that most high school students come to college two years too soon than they should.
There should be a two year hiatus where they go into the military or they go into, Peace Corps or just go
sling burgers at McDonald's and get your head on straight and figure out what your priorities are, and
then make up your mind that this is what you want to do. Because again, a lot of them are just kind of
going through the motions and-
GN (45:34):
They're maturing here, but while they're playing at it they're wasting some time.
TL (45:38):
Right. Yeah. And this, and if you're doing it for that reason, okay. That's a very expensive way to make a
decision, just kind of bite your time and try to take the four years to figure out what you want to do. I
had two nephews, they both went to state schools. One went to University of Connecticut and one we
went over here to SUNY New Paltz. They both got good educations. They're both well employed.
GN (46:15):
Happy?
TL (46:16):
Yeah. One's working, one's went and got his MBA and now his CPA. He's working for a big firm
down...one of the major five accounting firms and seems...living down in the city and things seems really
happy. The other majored over here in New Paltz in history and he's got himself a nice job teaching
history at a high school down in Queens and seems very happy. And so...but I think it all depends on the
kind of school you go to, I think. When I went to University of Bridgeport and at that time there were
about 4,000 undergraduates. Roughly the size of mirrors. When I went for my PhD at Michigan State,
there were 45,000 students. The freshmen class was 10,000 students. And I mean, you could tell, I
mean, these kids were shell-shocked for months. I mean, they just had this glazed look in your eye and
you can pick them off the sidewalk. There's a freshmen, there's, I mean, just by this glaze look in their
eye...so I mean, they were living in 17-story dormitories and stuff like that. And you know, their classes
were in the hundreds students, if not-
GN (47:31):
I like to throw out a, I just,
TL (47:33):
Well, and I took...one of the courses they wanted me to take, they said, well, you need to have some
programming. So they made me take a Fortran programming course. There were 1200 students in the
class meeting at the same time; everybody met the same time, the same day, but we met in 12 different
locations. And the instructor was on a TV screen. so 1200 students sitting, watching 12 different screens
with a graduate student who was given five minutes at the end of the class to answer any questions you
might have. So as an undergraduate, would I have thrived in that kind of environment? No way. So I
mean, I was a biology major at the University of Bridgeport. I was in a class of like 30-35 most of the
time. And we traveled together the whole four years. So we were in the same chemistry class, same
biology classes, et cetera. So yeah, it was a small group that basically traveled together through the four
years. And so I think smaller is better.
GN (48:35):
I was totally impressed here at Marist you guys in the science had your labs...Bettencourt was in there
from morning till night, weekends included, you know. And I say, that kind of contact, which leads to
my-
TL (48:48):
Which you wouldn't get at a much bigger school.
GN (48:50):
Right.
TL (48:52):
Or it would be a graduate student-
GN (48:54):
Working with you.
TL (48:58):
Yeah, and even they would limit their time because teaching was not their primary responsibility or
interest. They were just doing it for their financial support, their assistantships.
GN (49:11):
Lastly, why did you stay here so long?
TL (49:15):
Well I mean I like to say I liked the people. I liked the campus. So I mean-
GN (49:27):
You weren't very well paid. You were paid but not-
TL (49:30):
Well, I was paid maybe comparably to what I was making out in New Mexico. It was higher, but the cost
of living is higher here, so taxes are higher here than they were in New Mexico. So on face value it looks
like I was making more money than I probably was making in terms of actual spending power, I probably
wasn't making any more or any less than that out there. But all my family were back in this area. My
wife and I were the only two that sort of wandered off, and I'd been gone for 17 years basically. And our
parents were still...all of our parents were still alive, but getting older and so, okay this isn't going to last
forever. So yeah, it was, it was a mix of family, location. I mean, I'm a fisherman, so I mean I had the
Hudson River and all these fly fishing opportunities all around. The people, I mean Marist was very
welcoming when I came. We used to sit and--like you said--we used to sit around at lunch time in
Donnelley Hall. Everybody was on the same schedule. We all had that lunch hour free. You and Liz and
Andy and Rosemary and Cecily and Mark VanderHeyden and Richard LaPietra and Joe-
GN (50:54):
People going up to the board to explain certain things.
TL (50:54):
Yeah. Lynne Doty, Judith Saunders. All the different people who used to wander in and out during-
GN (50:59):
But now I understand you can't have lunch in the lab anymore. They took...see you environmentalists-
TL (51:04):
Well then as soon as they...as soon as Mark VanderHeyden changed the schedule to the present
schedule, now everybody was on a different lunch. There wasn't a common lunch hour anymore. So
then that all just kind of faded away, people started eating at their desk or whatever. And so all that was
kind of lost, which I think is a shame. The other problem I see with the school of science is--and I knew
this was going to happen and Kathy Newkirk confirmed it for me just the other day--is they've split the
school between two locations at this point. So they've got the biology department and they've got the
athletic training people over in the new science building. They've got chemistry and environmental
science over in Donnelley, and very rarely do those two groups ever get together. And so as time goes
by, you're just going to see a-
GN (52:02):
A demise?
TL (52:02):
Well not...I mean just people drifting away. You know, you don't...new faculty are coming in, old faculty
are leaving, the people who are in one building don't get to know the people in the other building the
way we did when everybody sat around the table every day, five days a week having lunch together. So I
think that's a negative as a result of the growth.
GN (52:27):
Is there a consistency though in the Marist spirit as such? I mean, people are welcoming by and large. I
sense that among the students that there's a basic simplicity. They still hold a door for you, which is-
TL (52:44):
Right. And my wife, she used to work in student services over at Vassar college. And so I had
opportunities to be on the Vassar campus on numerous occasions. And you could tell. I mean, it's just a
different culture. It's a different student body. I mean, just from the way they dress-- tattoos, body
piercings. Political activity, social consciousness. So in some respects Marists students are a little bit less-
GN (53:26):
Avant Garde? [Chuckles]
TL (53:26):
Well, they're a little bit less active, a little bit less outspoken, a little bit less politically involved on social
issues and stuff then something like a Bard or Vassar. So you could tell...if you put a Marist student and
a Vassar student, if you picked 10 and 10, say which one is which, I predict I could probably...eight out of
10, I could pick them, I can peg them as to which campus they had come from. So yeah, so...but I mean,
like you say, I mean Marist students, I mean they've always been really nice kids. Very polite, very
respectful.
GN (54:12):
Yeah. I think they draw each other too. I mean, there's a magnet. They want to bring like unto like.
TL (54:20):
And I think they tend to help each other studying, at least in the sciences. I mean forming study groups
and working together and looking out for each other and stuff like that, so.
GN (54:35):
Good. I've said everything I wanted to say. Is there something you'd like to say in closing of this?
TL (54:41):
I think we've covered a lot of ground.
GN (54:43):
We did. And so with that, thank you very much Tom, it's been a real pleasure.
TL (54:47):
Yeah. Thank you.